FMC Announces Investigation Into Flags of Convenience and Unfavorable Conditions Created by Flagging Practices

Matthew J. Thomas, Jeanne M. Grasso, Kierstan L. Carlson, and Natalie M. Radabaugh ●

The U.S. Federal Maritime Commission (“FMC”) announced on May 21, 2025 that it is initiating a non-adjudicatory investigation into whether the: 1) vessel flagging laws, regulations, and/or practices of certain foreign governments, including the so-called flags of convenience (“FOC” or “open registries”), or 2) competitive methods employed by owners, operators, agents, or masters of foreign-flag vessels, are creating unfavorable shipping conditions in the foreign trade of the United States (the “Notice”).

The investigation includes a 90-day public comment period, which ends on August 20, 2025. 

FMC’s “Section 19” Trade Authority

Section 19 of the Merchant Marine Act of 1920, 46 U.S.C. § 42101 et seq., authorizes the FMC to evaluate conditions that affect U.S. shipping in foreign trade and to issue regulations or take action to address such conditions. Potential remedies include port fees up to one million U.S. dollars, limits on voyages to and from U.S. ports or the amount or type of cargo carried, and other trade restrictions.

The FMC exercised this authority frequently in the 1980s and 90s (before the sell-off of the major U.S. liner operators to foreign buyers) to force market-opening concessions and eliminate discriminatory fees and trade barriers that impeded U.S. shipping companies’ competitiveness in overseas. However, these powers have been left nearly dormant for the past two decades.

Continue reading “FMC Announces Investigation Into Flags of Convenience and Unfavorable Conditions Created by Flagging Practices”

The FMC Announces Investigation into Flags of Convenience and Unfavorable Conditions Created by Flagging Practices

Matthew J. ThomasJeanne M. Grasso, Kierstan L. Carlson, Natalie M. Radabaugh 

The U.S. Federal Maritime Commission (“FMC”) announced on May 21, 2025 that it is initiating a non-adjudicatory investigation into whether the: 1) vessel flagging laws, regulations, and/or practices of certain foreign governments, including the so-called flags of convenience, or 2) competitive methods employed by owners, operators, agents, or masters of foreign-flag vessels, are creating unfavorable shipping conditions in the foreign trade of the United States.

The investigation includes a 90-day public comment period, which ends on August 20, 2025. 

FMC’s “Section 19” Trade Authority

Section 19 of the Merchant Marine Act of 1920, 46 U.S.C. § 42101 et seq., authorizes the FMC to evaluate conditions that affect shipping in the U.S. foreign trade and to issue regulations or take action to address such conditions. Potential remedies include port fees up to one million dollars, limits on voyages to and from U.S. ports or the amount or type of cargo carried, and other trade restrictions.

The FMC exercised this authority frequently in the 1980s and 90s (before the sell-off of the major U.S. liner operators to foreign buyers) to force market-opening concessions and eliminate discriminatory fees and trade barriers that impeded U.S. shipping companies’ competitiveness overseas. However, these powers have been left nearly dormant for the past two decades.

The current investigation does not target particular flag States or propose any remedial measures; rather, it is a non-adjudicatory investigation pursuant to 46 C.F.R. Part 502, Subpart R, which allows the FMC to request information, conduct hearings, issue subpoenas, conduct depositions, and issue reports, at its discretion.

To read or download the full client alert, please visit our website.

Exit mobile version
%%footer%%